Introduction
A metal strap with holes — perforated hanger strap, plumber’s tape, pipe strap — is one of the cheapest products on a truck and one of the easiest to buy wrong. The wrong gauge sags under a water line; the wrong coating rusts through in a crawl space; the wrong hole pitch makes installers drill on site. We manufacture perforated steel strapping at our Jiangmen facility and have spent 16 years watching what happens to these products in the field, so for this 2026 listicle we combined manufacturer knowledge with current retail data: live prices and listings from Home Depot, Ace Hardware, Amazon, and trade suppliers, checked in November 2026. Every pick below names its gauge, width, length, and real street price, so you can compare on numbers rather than packaging.
Quick Comparison
| Rank | Product | Best For | Gauge / Width / Length | Approx. Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Oatey 33923 | Overall retail pick | 28 ga / 3/4 in / 10 ft | $6–8 |
| 2 | Simpson Strong-Tie HRS12 | Structural framing | 12 ga / 1-3/8 in / 12 in | $4–6 |
| 3 | Master Flow 3/4HS | HVAC duct hanging | 28 ga / 3/4 in / 100 ft | $15–25 |
| 4 | Gardner Bender GHS-1510 | Heavy plumbing (20 ga) | 20 ga / 3/4 in / 10 ft | $3.59 |
| 5 | Sioux Chief 524-1022PK2 | Pro plumbing supply | 22 ga / 3/4 in / 10 ft | $4–7 |
| 6 | Duro Dyne PGS24 | HVAC wholesale | 24 ga / 3/4 in / coiled | per 100 ft |
| 7 | Southwire 1702.4R | Conduit one-hole | 3/4 in EMT / 1 hole | $0.83 ea |
| 8 | Dottie PT26 | Electrical trade | 26 ga / 3/4 in / 10 ft | $3–5 |
| 9 | HYDRO MASTER | Amazon DIY value | 24 ga / 3/4 in / 10 ft | $8–12 |
| 10 | Gisafai 2-Roll | Bulk DIY 100 ft | 24 ga / 3/4 in / 2×50 ft | $18–25 |
| 11 | K&S Precision Metals | Hobby brass | 0.032 in / 1/2 in / 12 in | $25–30 |
| 12 | Jiangmen Masters | OEM / bulk import | custom / any width / coils | MOQ quotes |
#1. Oatey 33923 — Best Overall Metal Strap with Holes
Oatey owns the retail shelf, and the 33923 shows why: 3/4 in wide, 28 gauge, 10 ft of smooth galvanized strap with pre-punched holes every inch, bagged at roughly $6–8 on Amazon and Home Depot. It cuts with snips, takes a #8 or #10 screw through any hole, and holds typical residential water lines and conduit without complaint. The trade-off is gauge: 28 ga is a light-duty strap — right for hanging, wrong for anything structural.
#2. Simpson Strong-Tie HRS12 — Best for Structural Framing
The HRS12 is not a plumbing strap at all: 12 gauge (0.105 in), 1-3/8 in wide, G90 galvanized, and engineer-specified for framing connections. It is the product to reach for when the load is a beam or a header, not a pipe — real street price runs $4–6 at fastener suppliers. If your “strap with holes” has to carry structure, this is the standard the rest of the list is judged against.
#3. Master Flow 3/4HS — Best for HVAC Duct Hanging
Master Flow (Amerimax) sells the HVAC trade’s default: 28 gauge galvanized perforated strap in 100 ft rolls at Home Depot and the wider 1-1/2 in HS1.5S28 for ducts. The 100 ft format is the point — duct runs eat strap by the foot, and buying 10 ft bags is a false economy for pros. Master Flow rates the 28 ga strap at roughly 50 lb working load, which matches what we would advise for hanging only.
#4. Gardner Bender GHS-1510 — Best Heavy-Gauge Value
At $3.59 for 10 ft at Ace Hardware, the GHS-1510 is the cheapest 20 gauge strap on the market — a full two gauges heavier than most retail straps for about half the typical price. Twenty gauge bends less willingly than 28 ga, which is exactly why you buy it: heavier water lines and anything that must not sag.
#5. Sioux Chief 524-1022PK2 — Best Pro Plumbing Supply Pick
Sioux Chief is what wholesalers stock for contractors: 3/4 in × 10 ft, 22 gauge, galvanized, sold through supply houses like Raptor Supplies. The 22 gauge sits in the sweet spot between the flimsy retail 28 ga and the stiff 20 ga, and Sioux Chief’s consistency batch-to-batch is why inspectors rarely complain about it.
#6. Duro Dyne PGS24 — Best for HVAC Wholesale
Duro Dyne is the mechanical-contractor brand: the PGS24 perforated galvanized strap is 24 gauge, 3/4 in, sold coiled in quantity through HVAC distributors. It is the professional version of the same product: consistent hole pattern, clean deburred edges, and pricing by the 100 ft that beats retail bags at volume. If this is your first time buying perforated strap for a trade project, our what is perforated hanger strap primer covers the basics in five minutes.
#7. Southwire 1702.4R — Best for Conduit (One-Hole)
Southwire’s 1702.4R is a different animal: a 3/4 in EMT one-hole conduit strap at about $0.83 each from electrical suppliers. It is the electrical trade’s answer to “strap with holes” — rigid, zinc-plated, sized to a specific conduit. For running EMT on a wall, buy these; for hanging flexible bundles, stay with the band-type straps above.
#8. Dottie PT26 — Best Electrical Trade Plumber’s Tape
L.H. Dottie’s PT26 is the electrician’s plumber’s tape: 26 gauge galvanized steel, 3/4 in × 10 ft, stocked at electrical distributors like Platt Electric. It is the same perforated band product as #1 in a heavier gauge, priced for trade counters rather than retail shelves.
#9. HYDRO MASTER — Best Amazon DIY Value
HYDRO MASTER’s 3/4 in × 10 ft, 24 gauge strap is the current Amazon DIY favorite — 24 gauge (a step up from Oatey’s 28 ga) at roughly $8–12 with fast shipping. For a homeowner hanging one sink line or a curtain rod of conduit, this is the practical choice; check the hole spacing in the listing photos, because generic Amazon straps occasionally arrive with 2 in pitch where you expected 1 in.
#10. Gisafai 2-Roll — Best Bulk DIY 100 ft
Gisafai sells a two-roll pack of 24 gauge, 3/4 in × 50 ft strap — 100 ft total for around $18–25. That is about a third of the per-foot cost of 10 ft retail bags, which makes it the best home-gamer value when the project is long runs of pipe or conduit. The same 24 gauge caveats apply: fine for hanging, not for structure.
#11. K&S Precision Metals — Best Hobby Brass Strap
K&S Precision Metals’ brass strip with holes (0.032 in × 1/2 in × 12 in, 12 pieces around $86 or assorted packs at $25) is the model-maker’s version of the product. It will not hang a pipe, but for RC builds, jewelry, and miniature fabrication it is the reference brand — included here because hobbyists search the same phrase.
#12. Jiangmen Masters — Best OEM / Bulk Import Source
If you buy strap by the pallet rather than the bag, this is where the retail brands above get their product: our perforated hanger strap runs in any width, 22–28 gauge, G30–G90 zinc, straight or wavy edge, 3/16 in or 1/4 in holes on 1 in or 2 in centers, in retail rolls or bulk coils. Distributors and private-label buyers skip the retail markup entirely — request a quote on our contact page with your annual volume, and see our supplier vetting guide before shortlisting factories.
Brand Comparison: What Separates Them
Retail brands compete on shelf presence and packaging; trade brands (Duro Dyne, Sioux Chief, Dottie) compete on batch consistency and distribution; the manufacturer tier competes on raw material and tooling. That difference shows in two places: tolerance and traceability. A retail strap may vary visibly in hole pitch across the roll; a trade or OEM strap must hold ±0.005 in on hole diameter and consistent pitch, because it is written into the specification — see our specification page for the full dimensional tables.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Retail (Oatey, HYDRO MASTER) | Trade (Sioux Chief, Duro Dyne, Dottie) | Structural (Simpson HRS) | OEM Bulk (Jiangmen Masters) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical gauge | 24–28 | 22–26 | 12 | 22–28, custom |
| Hole pattern | 3/16 in @ 1 in | 3/16 in @ 1 in | nail slots, code-spaced | custom dia & pitch |
| Coating | galvanized (G30–G60) | galvanized G60 | G90 | G30 / G60 / G90 |
| Packaging | 10 ft bags | 10 ft / coils | 12 in pieces | rolls / bulk coils |
| Best use | DIY hanging | pro plumbing & HVAC | framing connections | distribution, private label |
Pricing Comparison (Checked November 2026)
| Product | Unit | Street Price | Normalized per 100 ft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gardner Bender GHS-1510 | 10 ft, 20 ga | $3.59 | ≈ $36 |
| Oatey 33923 | 10 ft, 28 ga | $6–8 | ≈ $60–80 |
| Gisafai 2-roll | 100 ft total, 24 ga | $18–25 | ≈ $18–25 |
| Master Flow 3/4HS | 100 ft, 28 ga | $15–25 | ≈ $15–25 |
| Simpson HRS12 | 12 in, 12 ga | $4–6 | n/a (structural) |
| Jiangmen Masters | bulk coils | MOQ quote | lowest at volume |
Prices are approximate street prices from Home Depot, Ace Hardware, Amazon, and trade suppliers at the time of writing; click through the linked listings for current numbers. For a deeper look at the product category itself, see our guide to metal strapping with holes.
Which Metal Strap with Holes Should You Choose?
- Hanging one pipe at home: Oatey 33923 or HYDRO MASTER — 10 ft, cut it, screw it, done.
- Re-piping or long conduit runs: Gisafai or Master Flow 100 ft rolls — the per-foot math beats bags.
- Professional plumbing jobs: Sioux Chief 22 ga or Gardner Bender 20 ga — heavier gauge, supply-house consistency.
- HVAC duct systems: Duro Dyne or Master Flow in coils, sized per duct width.
- Structural connections: Simpson Strong-Tie HRS — and only Simpson, because a framing strap is an engineered product.
- Reselling, importing, or private label: buy from the manufacturer tier — that is us — and specify your exact spec once.
Gauge is the decision that matters most; if you are unsure between 28 and 24, our 28 vs 24 gauge comparison settles it with load numbers, and how strong is perforated hanger strap walks through the working-load math.
FAQ
- What is the best metal strap with holes overall? For most buyers, the Oatey 33923 (28 gauge, 3/4 in × 10 ft) is the best all-round retail pick; for volume or professional use, move to 22–24 gauge trade straps or bulk coils.
- What gauge metal strap with holes should I use? 28 gauge for light hanging, 24 gauge for general plumbing and HVAC, 22–20 gauge for heavier lines, and 12 gauge structural straps only for engineered framing.
- Are all perforated hanger straps galvanized? Most are, but coating weight varies — G30 is dry-indoor only, G60 is the general standard, and G90 or stainless is required for wet or outdoor exposure.
- Can I buy metal strap with holes in bulk? Yes — manufacturers supply it in bulk coils or retail rolls with custom widths, gauges, hole patterns, and edge types, typically with a minimum order quantity.
Conclusion
The 12 picks above cover every buyer of a metal strap with holes in 2026 — from a $6 bag at the hardware store to a container of custom coils. The pattern across all of them is the same: hanging loads are light-duty work for 24–28 gauge galvanized strap, structural loads belong to 12 gauge engineered strap, and volume belongs to the manufacturer tier. Whatever you choose, verify the three numbers on the label — gauge, width, and hole pitch — and the strap will do exactly what the package promises. For bulk inquiries, samples, and custom specifications, download our product catalogs or contact us through the contact page — we manufacture the galvanized substrate to ASTM A653 and answer every RFQ within 24 hours.